The relationship between the early definitions of both religion and
magic is quite fascinating. On the one hand, many people believe that
Christianity is very much against magic and witchcraft because it
correlates with the Devil, and supports the idea of working for
Satan. Yet it is interesting to note that during the time
Christianity was first established – a time when magic was actually
accepted as a useful tool in society – Christianity seemed to have
many similar traits as to witchcraft.
Michael Bailey noted in his article, "The Rise of Christianity
and Early Medieval Europe to the Year 1000," that this was a
very controversial issue in the development of the religious group.
However, Bailey distinguishes the differences between Christianity
and witchcraft right away. He stated that while witchcraft, as
mentioned earlier, involves working with the Devil and demons,
Christianity had a more divine intention. Both rites had a sense of
power to them, but while witchcraft seemed to be labeled with a more
wicked intention, Christianity was seen as an act from the Christian
God (Bailey 44). Of course, Bailey notes later on in the chapter that
many people still took part in magic as a means of getting something
they want or need – such as a mother wanting to save her sick
child.
It's still a controversial topic even in today's society, but it is
interesting to see the dynamic between the two groups.
Bailey, Michael. Magic and Superstition in Europe. Plymouth: Rowan and Littlefield, 2007. Print.
Question:
1. What do you think about the connection between Christianity and
magic? Do you think there is a connection at all?
My post was actually on the same topic. One thing that really stood out to me was the accusations of Jesus actually being a magician. To the casual observer he really does seem to fit many of the traits attributed to wizards or magicians. There are a lot of interesting parallels between the two especially when you really take a good look at it.
ReplyDelete